Generally, it involves comparisons of social processes across times and places. American capital punishment in comparative perspective law. The enduring institution of capital punishment in historical and comparative perspective david johnson and michael w. Essay on the history and evolution of punishment for crime. The authors survey punishment responses to crime and deviance across different regions of the world and in. A southern african perspective on fundamental criminology. The history of corporal punishment download ebook pdf, epub. Punishment a comparative historical perspective cambridge university press from indonesia 101 at sma negeri 4 bekasi. Pdf comparative criminal justice download read online. It probes the concerns underlying the naval, prison, domestic, and educational reform campaigns which occurred in new england and new york from the late 1820s to the late 1850s. Comparative historical analysis is a primary method of exploration in the social sciences. There is an enormous academic and popular literature on punishment. Normative arguments about just punishment for crime.
Introduction a person under the age of 18 in malaysia a is protected under the child act 2001, the juvenile courts act 1947, the. One form of punishment that has existed since the beginning of society is capital punishment. Evolution of capital punishment ever since there has been crime, there has been punishment. As crime and societies have evolved over time, so have capital punishment, its forms, and its reasons for use. Crime and punishment was published in 1866 and is one of dostoevskys four great masterpieces, murder stories all. Contemporary punishments in comparative perspective. Critical analysis of theories of punishment mere denunciation of crime is not enough. Punishment means, it is the redress that the commonwealth takes against an offending member1punishment is. Importantly, this question about the currency of punishment is conceptually distinct from the central question i examine here about the boundaries of punishment. Punishment and control in historical perspective h.
Welfare and punishment in comparative perspective the past three decades of work on the soci al analysis of punishment have arguably neglected the impact of the commitment to welfare on the scale. This book is designed to identify and examine the sources of similarity and differences in types of economic punishments, incapacitation devices and structures, and lethal and nonlethal forms of corporal punishment over time and place. Nations are not helpless if the military decides to stage a coup. Cambridge core criminology punishment by terance d. Pdf welfare and punishment in comparative perspective. In the 20th century, however, torture became much more common.
Part of thecriminal law commons,criminology commons, and thecriminology and criminal justice commons this article is brought to you for free and open access by northwestern university school of law scholarly commons. Miethe, hong lu this book identifies and examines the sources of similarities and differences in types of economic punishments, incapacitation devices and structures, and lethal and nonlethal forms of corporal punishment over time and place. In iran the punishment for adultery among other things is to be buried waist deep and stoned. Campaigns against corporal punishment explores the theory and practice of punishment in antebellum america from a broad, comparative perspective. China, england, france, germany, japan, and saudi arabia. Sep 01, 2011 american capital punishment in asian perspective peculiar institution reveals much that is true and important about capital punishment in america, and one key to its success is a comparative perspective which locates the united states in a broad western context. In addition, the punishment for drug smuggling is a public beheading. Countries covered include great britain, the netherlands, belgium, scandinavia. Johnson and others published chinese capital punishment in comparative perspective find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. The enduring institution of capital punishment in historical and comparative perspective. A comparative analysis between the united states and china will be presented. A comparative historical analysis of american immigration control, 19902017 article pdf available. Punishment a comparative historical perspective cambridge. American capital punishment in comparative perspective, law.
Sociological perspectives view punishment as a complex social institution, shaped by an ensemble of social and historical forces and having a range of effects that reach well beyond the population of offenders. On dozens of occasions in recent decades, even in the face of intimidated political. Comparative perspectives the cultural lives of law sarat, austin on. Consensual procedures and the avoidance of the full criminal trial, carolina academic press. The contributors explore the distinctive national differences in policy responses to rising crime rates, rapid social change, economic dislocation and increased ethnic diversity. Beccaria s view, swift and certain punishment are the best means of preventing and controlling crime. An historical and comparative perspective on the theory and practice of avoiding the full trial 2010. It has been a means of manipulating and disciplining children to conform to familial and social rules, norms and values. Punishment means, it is the redress that the commonwealth takes against an offending member1punishment is some sort of social.
Guided by existing macrolevel theories on punishment and society, the present. Warren stearns follow this and additional works at. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Though extreme, the result is a country with a very low reported rate of theft and drug smuggling. American capital punishment in comparative perspective. Indeed, any list of the most influential social scientists. It is often said that american capital punishment fulfills no purposes, serves no functions, and possesses no coherent rationale. The comparative historical analysis highlights the 1930s and 1940s as an era when ireland began to reject patria potestas and religious or. The criminal corpse has been and, in some contexts, continues to be a significant site of state power, criminal justice, scientific anatomy and popular medicine. Click download or read online button to get a southern african perspective on fundamental criminology book now. The enduring institution of capital punishment inhistorical and comparative perspective, in where are we on the road to abolition. Other branches sometimes tacitly approve of the punishment after the fact.
Through this comparative historical perspective, the reader should gain an appreciation of the universal and contextspecific nature of punishment practices. The goal of crime and justice, volume 36 is to advance the understanding of the determinants of penal policies in developed countries. Pdf comparative criminal justice download read online free. A comparative historical framework of analysis involving two case studies of ireland and ghana illustrates nonunilinear pathways of international convergence towards the prohibition of physical punishment. The durkheimian perspective interprets punishment as a. On dozens of occasions in recent decades, even in the face of intimidated political leaders and international indifference, civil society has risen up to challenge putschists through largescale nonviolent direct action and noncooperation. Sociologists and other social scientists have long been interested in the topic of punishment, social control, and the structure of society. Discourses on violence and punishment by kresimir petkovic. A comparative and historical analysis christopher j. It also puts violence and punishment into perspective with political power, world religions, literature and film, and criminological theory.
A comparative historical perspective terance miethe on amazon. The example is extreme, but one can imagine how such a punishment would deter. Miethe, professor of criminal justice terance d miethe, hong lu cambridge university press, 2005 social science 240 pages. An introduction 1 since the rise of the social sciences, researchers have used comparativehistorical methods to expand insight into diverse social phenomena and, in so doing, have made great contributions to our understanding of the social world. The comparative nature of punishment brooklyn law school. Corporal punishment has haunted the lives of many children still in many parts of the world. Those are paths leading to a better characterization of a specific region within europe, whose constituent countries share a number of similar features in their monetary and financial past. Beccaria and the classical theorists believed that humans are rational beings with free will to govern 234 deterrence theory dbosworth. Punishment serves a wide variety of functions, including retribution, deterrence, incapacitation, rehabilitation and behavioural shaping to comply with cultural norms.
This resource is also available in the following languages. A comparative historical perspective miethe, terance on. As the chapters in this volume show, various factors were at work in the practice of execution and the treatment of the executed body in the past, assuming different forms at different times and places. The study adopts a comparative historical framework based on what amenta and hicks 2010 refer to as deep knowledge social policy case studies ireland and ghana to illustrate tensions in different countries between normative child welfare initiatives and religious, customary family ideologies. The term crime does not, in modern criminal law, have any simple and universally accepted definition,1 though statutory definitions have been provided for certain purposes. Extrajudicial punishment may be planned and carried out by a particular branch of a state, without informing other branches, or even without having been ordered to commit such acts. At the time, the keeping of a felon under guard served predominantly two purposes. The history of corporal punishment download ebook pdf.
The increasingly important topic of comparative criminal justice is examined from an original and insightful perspective by one of the top scholars in the field. We anticipate doing so will demonstrate the value of a comparative historical perspective for studying crime, deviance, and punishment. Through a comparative historical analysis of punishment, this 2005 book is designed to identify and examine the sources of similarity and differences in types of economic punishments, incapacitation devices and structures, and lethal and nonlethal forms of corporal punishment over time and place. A comparative historical perspective this book identifies and examines the sources of. Jzwjrt 052184407xpre cb766miethev1 january 23, 2005 punishment in this unique textbook, which is scholarly yet accessible to students, miethe and lu approach punishment from a perspective that is both historical and comparative, addressing the global dimensions of punishment as few authors do. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read crime and culture. Its ambitious comparative and historical perspective, and in particular its interpretation of how institutional features of these societies develop over a long span of time, and of how criminal justice and other. Murder in crime and punishment was for personal ambition.
Americas death penalty in an age of abolition 2010, david garland argues that american capital punishment is functional, meaningful, and effective, especially in the cultural realm of death penalty discourse. Offering a comprehensive analysis, bestselling comparative criminal justice systems, 5e compares the various criminal justice systems throughout the world using six model countries. A comparative analysis between the united states and china will be presented as well, portraying two extremely different societies with. This article examines the extent to which one aspect of american societythe extensive use. Download the monograph pdf, 5 mb this resource is also available in the following languages. Miethe and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Baby dumping, comparative study, legislation, prevention, punishment. The authors look closely at punishment responses to crime and deviance across different regions of the world and in specific countries like the united states. Historical perspective on punishment and social structure. Comparative historical analysis in criminology and criminal justice presents exciting opportunities for research. Comparative historical research is a method of social science that examines historical events in order to create explanations that are valid beyond a particular time and place, either by direct comparison to other historical events, theory building, or reference to the present day. Addressing the need for a globalized criminology, david nelken looks at why we should study crime and criminal justice in a comparative and. It provides a critical analysis of institutions, punishment and the law, and explores. The term crime does not, in modern criminal law, have any simple and universally accepted definition,1 though statutory definitions have been provided for.
Pdf chinese capital punishment in comparative perspective. Lu approach punishment from a perspective that is both historical and comparative. The book illustrates the different types of law and justice systems while exploring the historical. Punishmentretribution, rehabilitation, and deterrence. Historical perspective on punishment and social structure chapter 2 what determines type of punishment. The purpose of this book is to explore punishments from a comparative historical perspective. Through a comparative historical analysis of punishment, this 2005 book is designed to identify and examine the sources of similarity and differences in types of economic punishments, incapacitation devices and structures, and lethal and nonlethal forms of corporal punishment over time and. Punishment, culture and society legal studies major. Changes in punishment should not be viewed solely through the lens of progressreform or as a cyclical patternpendulum systems of punishment can only be understood within a societys social, political, ideological, and economic context. Reviews contrasts in punishment will take a central place in the emerging literature seeking to explain persisting differences in levels and forms of punishment in modern societies.
863 206 555 912 100 967 1368 911 1519 451 508 1124 514 641 1299 641 1561 159 1132 670 1306 1211 328 175 731 1343 659 855 103 1486 323